Home - Baseball - The Art of Pitching: Lessons from Cy Young Award Winners

On This Page

The Art of Pitching: Lessons from Cy Young Award Winners

Dive into the fascinating history and significance of the prestigious Cy Young Award in this comprehensive article. Learn about the origins of the award, how it got its name, and the reasons behind its inception. Gain insight into the criteria, eligibility, and selection process, including the roles of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Discover notable winners and explore controversies surrounding the award, as well as its impact on the game of baseball. Finally, catch up on recent Cy Young Award winners and analyze the latest trends in the selection process.

Origins of the Cy Young Award

Creation of the award

The Cy Young Award was created in 1956 in honor of the legendary baseball pitcher Denton True “Cy” Young, who had passed away the previous year. The award was established by Commissioner Ford Frick and is presented annually to the best Major League Baseball (MLB) pitcher in the American League and the National League. Initially, only one pitcher from either the American League or National League was honored, but since 1967, the award has been given to the best pitcher in each league.

The decision to establish an award for the best pitcher was made because, at that time, there was no specific recognition for pitchers apart from the Most Valuable Player (MVP) Award in both leagues. Pitchers, being vital to any baseball team, deserved to be recognized separately from other field positions. The Cy Young Award was a move in this direction, aiming to commend the exceptional performances of pitchers and elevate their status in the baseball world.

Reasons for its inception

The main purpose behind the inception of the Cy Young Award was to recognize and reward the most outstanding pitchers in Major League Baseball. Before the creation of this award, pitchers were often overlooked for individual awards, as they seldom won the prestigious MVP award. This was due to the fact that pitchers play in fewer games each season compared to position players and had fewer opportunities to make an impact on the statistics that were considered important for MVP voting, such as batting average and runs batted in.

The Cy Young Award was created to fill this void and specifically honor the pitcher’s role in the game, recognizing their contributions to their team’s success. By creating an award dedicated to pitchers, the MLB acknowledged the critical nature of their position and the significant impact they have on the game. Moreover, it allowed fans and the baseball community to appreciate and celebrate some of the most exceptional pitching performances throughout the season.

Naming after Cy Young

The award was named after Cy Young, one of the most iconic and accomplished pitchers in baseball history. Young, who was born in Gilmore, Ohio, played professional baseball for twenty-two seasons. He won 511 games – a record that still stands today and is considered unbreakable. Along with his staggering win record, Young also completed 749 games and accumulated 2,803 strikeouts during his illustrious career. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1937, as one of the inaugural members.

Cy Young’s distinguished career and remarkable achievements in the world of baseball made him the perfect candidate to be honored with an award named after him. The Cy Young Award not only pays tribute to Young’s incredible talent and work ethic but also represents the high standards expected of the award recipients.

By naming the award after Cy Young, the MLB enshrined a lasting legacy in baseball history, celebrating the dedication and excellence of the best pitchers in the sport. Today, the Cy Young Award is one of the most prestigious honors a pitcher can receive, acknowledging the dedication, skill, and perseverance required to excel in their role.

Award Criteria and Selection Process

The selection process for baseball awards varies depending on the specific accolade. This analysis discusses the framework for determining eligibility criteria, the voting system, and the role of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA) in the process.

Award eligibility

For a player to be eligible for an award in baseball, specific criteria must be met. These criteria differ between awards, but some general qualifications often apply across the board. For instance, players need to be part of Major League Baseball (MLB), at least for most recognitions. Additionally, they must meet a minimum level of participation in the respective season under review.

Some awards, like the Most Valuable Player (MVP) and the Cy Young Award, are specifically aimed at rewarding the best-performing players in MLB. In such cases, voters typically consider the overall contribution a player has made to their team’s success. Factors such as batting average, home runs, team standing, fielding statistics, and other performance-related aspects are all taken into account.

Other awards may focus on unique achievements or characteristics in baseball. For example, the Rookie of the Year Award evaluates the best-performing first-year players, while the Gold Glove Award acknowledges outstanding fielding abilities.

Voting system

Once a player is deemed eligible for an award, the voting process often involves a pre-selected group of sports journalists and other members of the BBWAA. The methodology used to tally votes differs depending on the specific accolade under consideration but often employs a points system.

For instance, in the voting process for the MVP, each voter ranks their top ten selections for the award, assigning a point value to each athlete in descending order (10 points for the first choice, 9 points for the second, and so on). The player with the highest overall point total across all voters wins the award.

Other awards may feature variations in the voting methodology. For instance, the Hall of Fame selection process requires candidates to receive at least 75% of the vote from BBWAA members on the ballot to secure induction.

To maintain a level of impartiality, the BBWAA aims to diversify its voter base by including representatives from various regions and media outlets. Additionally, it’s common for the BBWAA to revise guidelines and voting processes as needed to address any loopholes or controversies.

Role of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America

The BBWAA is an essential component of the baseball award selection process. This organization, founded in 1908, consists of sports journalists covering Major League Baseball for various newspapers, magazines, and online media outlets.

In addition to their involvement in the voting system for awards, the BBWAA plays a significant role in shaping the overall criteria and regulations for these accolades. They often review eligibility requirements and revise them as necessary in response to feedback from their membership or the public.

Furthermore, the BBWAA helps promote consistency across the awarding process by adhering to established procedures and guidelines. Their involvement in the procedural aspects of the awards ensures that each year’s selections align with the historical context and values of the baseball community.

In summary, the baseball award selection process is a carefully designed framework involving clearly defined eligibility criteria, a structured voting system, and the oversight of the BBWAA. This system ensures that the most deserving players are accurately and fairly recognized for their contributions to the game.

Notable Cy Young Award Winners

First-time winners

The Cy Young Award is presented annually to the best Major League Baseball (MLB) pitchers, one each from the American League (AL) and National League (NL). Named after Hall of Fame pitcher Cy Young, the award was first introduced in 1956. Originally, it was given to the single best pitcher in the major leagues, but in 1967, the award was expanded to honor the best pitcher from each league. Some notable first-time winners include:

  1. Don Newcombe (1956) – The first-ever recipient of the Cy Young Award, Newcombe played for the Brooklyn Dodgers. In that season, he had a 27-7 win-loss record with a 3.06 earned run average (ERA).

  2. Sandy Koufax (1963) – Koufax earned the first of his three Cy Young Awards as a member of the Los Angeles Dodgers. He finished the ’63 season with a 25-5 record and a 1.88 ERA.

  3. Tom Seaver (1969) – As a member of the New York Mets, Seaver won his first Cy Young Award with a 25-7 record and a 2.21 ERA.

Multiple-time winners

Several pitchers have won the Cy Young Award multiple times. Among the most notable are:

  1. Roger Clemens – Winning a record seven Cy Young Awards, Clemens stands at the top of the list. He won the award with the Boston Red Sox, Toronto Blue Jays, New York Yankees, and Houston Astros.

  2. Randy Johnson – Johnson earned the Cy Young Award five times during his illustrious career. He won four consecutive awards with the Arizona Diamondbacks from 1999 to 2002 and one with the Seattle Mariners in 1995.

  3. Greg Maddux – The right-handed pitcher won the award four consecutive times from 1992 to 1995, becoming the first to achieve the feat. He won the award for both the Chicago Cubs and Atlanta Braves.

Unanimous winners

Unanimous winners of the Cy Young Award are those who have received all possible first-place votes from members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Notable unanimous selections include:

  1. Sandy Koufax (1965 and 1966) – In his back-to-back unanimous wins, Koufax dominated opposing hitters with exceptional control and a dominant fastball.

  2. Pedro Martinez (1999 and 2000) – Martinez became the first unanimous winner in both the American and National Leagues during his time with the Boston Red Sox and Montreal Expos.

  3. Clayton Kershaw (2014) – The Los Angeles Dodgers left-hander became the second unanimous NL winner since Randy Johnson in 2002.

Winners from both the American and National Leagues

A few pitchers have won Cy Young Awards in both the American and National Leagues. This rare feat demonstrates their adaptability and consistency across both leagues. Notable names include:

  1. Gaylord Perry – Perry won the AL award in 1972 with the Cleveland Indians and the NL award in 1978 with the San Diego Padres.

  2. Pedro Martinez – As mentioned earlier, Martinez earned the Cy Young Award in the NL with the Montreal Expos in 1997 and the AL with the Boston Red Sox in 1999 and 2000.

  3. Randy Johnson – After winning the Cy Young in the AL with the Seattle Mariners, Johnson took home four consecutive awards in the NL with the Arizona Diamondbacks.

  4. Roger Clemens – Clemens claimed the award in both leagues with the Red Sox, Blue Jays, Yankees, and Astros.

Controversies and Criticisms

Controversial selections

Although the Cy Young Award aims to honor the best pitcher in each league, the selection process has not been without controversy. For example, in 1999, some baseball fans argue that Mike Hampton should have won the award over Randy Johnson due to Hampton’s higher win total and lower ERA. Similar debates have taken place over other selections as well.

Criticisms of the voting process

The Cy Young Award voting process has faced criticism for its reliance on traditional statistics such as wins, strikeouts, and ERA. Modern advanced metrics like Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP), Wins Above Replacement (WAR), and others have emerged to provide a more accurate representation of a pitcher’s value. Critics argue that incorporating these advanced statistics would lead to more deserving winners.

Alternatives to the Cy Young Award

Given the criticisms of the Cy Young Award, some alternatives have been proposed. For instance, ESPN’s Cy Young Predictor combines traditional statistics with advanced metrics to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of a pitcher’s performance. End-of-season awards like The Sporting News Pitcher of the Year and the Players Choice Awards also serve as other outlets for recognizing exceptional pitchers. Regardless of these alternatives, the Cy Young Award remains one of the most prestigious honors in Major League Baseball.

Impact of the Cy Young Award on Baseball

The Cy Young Award is undoubtedly one of the most prestigious accolades in Major League Baseball (MLB). Established in 1956, it commemorates the exceptional accomplishments of Cy Young, one of baseball’s most legendary pitchers. The accolade is granted annually to the best pitchers in each league – the American League (AL) and the National League (NL). Throughout the years, the prominence of the Cy Young Award has had a far-reaching impact on baseball, including player recognition, Hall of Fame selections, and its overall contribution to the sport’s history and lore.

Influence on player recognition

By designating the best pitchers in both leagues, the Cy Young Award has held a substantial influence over the recognition and career trajectories of its recipients. Acquiring the award oftentimes propels pitchers into the spotlight, garnering the admiration of fans, respect from peers, and the acknowledgment of excellence by the MLB community as a whole.

For instance, Cy Young Award winners typically experience endorsement opportunities and increased media exposure. This recognition can catalyze further opportunities, such as being selected for All-Star games, becoming the face of a franchise, or attaining lucrative contracts. Such accolades can have a domino effect on players’ professional pathways, elevating status through heightened visibility.

Moreover, achieving Cy Young Award status often raises the expectations for a pitcher’s performance, both personally and professionally. As a result, recipients are tasked with upholding their reputation and showcasing their abilities in ways that continually solidify their status as exceptional baseball players.

Effect on Hall of Fame Selections

The Baseball Hall of Fame is where players, managers, and other important baseball figures are immortalized in recognition of their impact on the sport. Cy Young Award-winners, who have already been identified as exceptional pitchers in their respective leagues, are often looked upon favorably when it comes to Hall of Fame balloting.

Notably, garnering multiple Cy Young Awards considerably strengthens a player’s candidacy. A prime example is the legendary pitcher Roger Clemens, who amassed a record-breaking seven Cy Young Awards throughout his career. Fittingly, Clemens has been a perennial contender for Hall of Fame selections.

Additionally, consistent success can contribute to a player’s Hall of Fame candidacy as well. A Cy Young Award-track record of excellence over several years renders players prime candidates for admission into the Hall of Fame. The award’s reputation as a benchmark of pitching greatness serves to further emphasize its impact on players’ professional legacies.

Contribution to baseball history and lore

The Cy Young Award plays a defining role in cultivating baseball’s rich history and mythology. By recognizing the unparalleled achievements of pitchers, the accolade chronicles the tradition and folklore of the sport over the years.

As stipulated by its namesake, the Cy Young Award pays homage to one of baseball’s most storied pitchers, Denton True “Cy” Young. With an astounding 511 career wins, Cy Young’s legacy resonates through time, perpetuating the significance of the award in his honor.

Furthermore, the Cy Young Award and its recipients weave a narrative tapestry of baseball’s most iconic moments. For instance, Sandy Koufax’s unforgettable performance in the 1965 World Series is tightly interwoven with his three Cy Young Awards. Similarly, the captivating, record-setting seasons of pitchers such as Bob Gibson, Greg Maddux, and Pedro Martinez would hardly be complete without mention of their Cy Young Award-winning campaigns.

In summary, the Cy Young Award remarkably impacts baseball through player recognition, bearing influence on Hall of Fame selections, and bolstering the sport’s history and lore. As a beacon of distinction, the Cy Young Award remains a touchstone of pitching prowess, etching its recipients’ names into the annals of baseball lore.

Recent Cy Young Award Winners

The Cy Young Award, first introduced in 1956, is one of Major League Baseball’s (MLB) top honors. It is presented annually to the best pitcher in each league, one from the American League and one from the National League. The award is named after former professional baseball pitcher Cy Young, who remains the record-holder for most career wins in the MLB. Since its inception, numerous legendary pitchers have been honored with the prestigious award. In this article, we will take a closer look at the Cy Young Award winners from the past decade, and analyze recent trends in the selection process.

List of winners within the past 10 years

Starting from the most recent, here are the Cy Young Award winners from the past decade, five from the American League and five from the National League:

American League:
– 2020: Shane Bieber, Cleveland Guardians (then-called Cleveland Indians)
– 2019: Justin Verlander, Houston Astros
– 2018: Blake Snell, Tampa Bay Rays
– 2017: Corey Kluber, Cleveland Guardians (then-called Cleveland Indians)
– 2016: Rick Porcello, Boston Red Sox

National League:
– 2020: Trevor Bauer, Cincinnati Reds
– 2019: Jacob deGrom, New York Mets
– 2018: Jacob deGrom, New York Mets
– 2017: Max Scherzer, Washington Nationals
– 2016: Max Scherzer, Washington Nationals

Out of the above-mentioned recent winners, a few stand out for their impressive performances. Jacob deGrom from the New York Mets received back-to-back awards in 2018 and 2019, showcasing his dominant presence on the mound. Additionally, Max Scherzer from the Washington Nationals also claimed back-to-back Cy Young Awards in 2016 and 2017, further emphasizing his impressive skillset as a pitcher.

Analysis of recent trends in the selection process

As we analyze the trends observed in the Cy Young Award selection process over the past decade, a few patterns emerge. Some of the notable trends include the preference for starting pitchers, the impact of advanced analytics on the voting process, and the attention paid to various statistical categories such as ERA (earned run average), WHIP (walks plus hits per innings pitched), and strikeouts.

  1. Preference for starting pitchers: The majority of recent Cy Young Award winners have been starting pitchers, as they usually pitch more innings throughout the season and have a more significant impact on the overall performance of their teams. However, this does not mean that relief pitchers are completely disregarded during the voting process. There have been some cases where relief pitchers have received votes, but ultimately, starting pitchers have dominated the Cy Young Award winners list in recent history.

  2. Impact of advanced analytics: In the modern age of baseball, the use of advanced analytics has become more common among teams and analysts. These statistics can often provide a more accurate representation of a pitcher’s performance and help evaluators determine the best pitcher in the league more effectively. Metrics such as Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP), Wins Above Replacement (WAR), and others contribute to the overall assessment of a pitcher’s abilities.

  3. Statistical achievements: Traditional stats, such as ERA and WHIP, continue to play an essential role in determining Cy Young Award winners. Typically, pitchers with low ERAs and WHIPs are considered more effective at preventing runs and limiting base runners, respectively. Additionally, the number of strikeouts tallied by a pitcher can be a significant factor in the selection process, as high strikeout rates often demonstrate a more dominant presence on the mound.

In conclusion, the Cy Young Award remains a prestigious honor for MLB pitchers, and recent winners have showcased exceptional talent and dominance in their respective leagues. From deGrom’s back-to-back wins to Verlander’s continued success, the past decade of Cy Young Award winners highlights some of the game’s greatest pitchers. As baseball continues to evolve, the use of advanced analytics and the focus on specific statistical categories will become increasingly significant during the voting process.

Cy Young Award Winners-FAQs

1. What is the Cy Young Award, and why is it significant?

The Cy Young Award, named in honor of Baseball Hall of Famer Cy Young, is presented annually to the best pitchers in Major League Baseball (MLB). Its significance stems from recognizing outstanding achievement and celebrating top pitching talent in both the American and National Leagues.

2. How is the Cy Young Award winner determined?

Members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA) determine the Cy Young Award winner. Each voter selects five pitchers, ranking them in a weighted voting system. The highest point scorers, one from each league, receive the prestigious award.

3. Who was the first Cy Young Award winner?

The first Cy Young Award winner was Don Newcombe in 1956. Newcombe, a talented pitcher for the Brooklyn Dodgers, won the inaugural award when only one recipient was chosen across both leagues.

4. Have any pitchers won the Cy Young Award multiple times?

Yes, numerous pitchers have earned the Cy Young Award more than once. Among the most impressive multi-time winners are Roger Clemens (7 times), Randy Johnson (5 times), and Greg Maddux (4 times).

5. Can a reliever win the Cy Young Award?

Although primarily awarded to starting pitchers, relief pitchers are also eligible for the Cy Young Award. A few relievers, such as Rollie Fingers, Bruce Sutter, and Dennis Eckersley, have won the award.

6. What other accolades and achievements do Cy Young Award winners often possess?

Many Cy Young Award winners also have other distinguished achievements, such as World Series championships, MVP awards, and All-Star selections. Some winners have also been inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, further solidifying their legacies.

More Posts

When Did CT Legalize Gambling?

Connecticut has a rich history of gambling, with a diverse range of options available to residents. From casinos and horse racing tracks to the ever-popular

What Is The Best Sportsbook App In CT?

Imagine this: you’re a sports enthusiast in Connecticut, eagerly looking for the best sportsbook app to elevate your betting experience. Get ready to discover the

Does CT Tax Gambling Winnings?

Did you know that Connecticut imposes income tax on gambling winnings? That’s right, if you’ve hit the jackpot or had a lucky streak at the

Table of Contents


Send Us A Message