Home - Baseball - The Ugly Hidden Realities of Minor League Baseball Umpires

On This Page

The Ugly Hidden Realities of Minor League Baseball Umpires

Have you ever wondered what it takes to be a Minor League Baseball Umpire? In this article, we uncover the untold story of the most challenging job on the field. From enforcing rules and regulations to maintaining order on the field, we explore the various responsibilities that come with the job.

We also take a deep dive into the rigorous training and development process of these umpires, including the intensive umpire schools, education programs, and evaluations they undergo. Join us as we take a closer look at the world of Minor League Baseball Umpires and the vital role they play in ensuring fair and safe play on the field

Moreover, the article sheds light on the different officiating levels in the Minor League, as well as the career progression and promotion to Major League Baseball. Lastly, we discuss the challenges faced by Minor League Umpires, such as travel and lifestyle adjustments, lower pay, and handling pressure, and highlight some notable Minor League Umpires who eventually made it to the MLB.

Role and Responsibilities of Minor League Baseball Umpires

Minor League Baseball umpires play a crucial role in overseeing and managing the game of baseball at the minor league level. Their primary responsibility is to ensure fair play and the enforcement of rules and regulations, while maintaining order on the field. The umpires are also responsible for communication with players and coaches and must be well-versed in the rules of the game. In this article, we will explore the various roles and responsibilities of minor league baseball umpires, including their duties before, during, and after the game.

Duties before the Game

Before the start of any minor league baseball game, umpires must ensure that the field is properly prepared and meets the required standards. This includes checking the condition of the field, bases, home plate, and pitcher’s mound for safety and playability. Umpires are also responsible for inspecting all equipment used in the game, such as bats, balls, helmets, and catcher’s gear, to ensure that they conform to league specifications and are safe for use.

Additionally, umpires meet with both teams’ managers before the game to discuss ground rules, answer any questions, and address any concerns. This meeting helps set the tone for the game and ensures that everyone is on the same page regarding the rules and regulations. Umpires will also typically review the game lineup with the managers and remind them of any special league rules that may be in effect.

Enforcing Rules and Regulations

During the game, it is the responsibility of the minor league baseball umpires to enforce all rules and regulations set forth by the league. This includes calling balls and strikes, making fair and foul calls, deciding when a runner is safe or out, and determining when a batter has been hit by a pitch.

Umpires must also be vigilant in spotting rule violations, such as illegal pitching motions, batter interference, and fielding errors. They are responsible for enforcing all penalties and repercussions for rule violations, which may include issuing warnings, ejecting players or coaches from the game, and making calls that result in runs being scored or taken away.

Maintaining Order on the Field

One of the primary responsibilities of a minor league baseball umpire is to maintain order on the field at all times. This involves managing disputes between players, coaches, and other umpires, as well as keeping emotions in check. Umpires have the authority to remove any player, coach, or team personnel from the game if they engage in unsportsmanlike conduct, such as arguing calls, using profanity, or inciting altercations.

Umpires must also ensure that the game progresses smoothly and without unnecessary delays. This may involve keeping the pace of play moving, encouraging batters to step up to the plate promptly, and ensuring that player substitutions and mound visits are executed within the allowable time limits.

Communication with Players and Coaches

Effective communication is essential for minor league baseball umpires, as they must frequently interact with players and coaches from both teams. Umpires need to be able to clearly and effectively communicate their calls and decisions, answer questions about rules and regulations, and address any concerns or issues that may arise during the game.

To maintain transparency and credibility, minor league baseball umpires must be consistent in their call-making and should always be prepared to explain the rationale behind their decisions. Establishing open lines of communication with players and coaches enables umpires to maintain a respectful and professional working relationship with all parties involved in the game.

Game Reporting and Documentation

After the conclusion of a minor league baseball game, umpires are responsible for completing various administrative tasks. This includes filling out an official game report that details the final score, player statistics, and any notable events or incidents that occurred during the game.

In addition to the game report, minor league baseball umpires must also document any warnings, ejections, or disciplinary actions that were taken during the game. This documentation is submitted to the league office and serves as a record of the umpire’s actions and decisions during the game.

In summary, the role and responsibilities of minor league baseball umpires extend beyond simply making calls on the field. These dedicated professionals are entrusted with ensuring the fairness, safety, and integrity of the game at the minor league level. By diligently executing their duties before, during, and after the game, umpires play a pivotal role in promoting sportsmanship, fair competition, and respect for the game of baseball.

Minor League Umpire Training and Development

Umpire Schools and Education Programs

Aspiring professional umpires typically begin their journey by attending one of the two accredited umpire schools in the United States. These schools, the Wendelstedt Umpire School and the Minor League Baseball Umpire Training Academy, are authorized by Minor League Baseball and Major League Baseball to present students with the training, knowledge, and skills necessary to officiate baseball games at all levels, from amateur to professional.

Students at these schools receive comprehensive instruction on the rules of baseball, game management, communication, and mechanics. In most cases, prospective umpires devote four to five weeks to their training at either school. The course curriculum includes a combination of classroom lectures, on-field instruction, video analysis, and simulated game situations.

Upon completion of umpire school, the top graduates are chosen to attend the Minor League Baseball Advanced Course. This additional program, held annually in Florida, provides selected students with the opportunity to build upon the skills learned at umpire school and fine-tune their officiating abilities in preparation for a job in professional baseball.

Key Skills and Qualifications

To be considered for a position as a minor league umpire, candidates must possess a number of key skills and qualifications, aside from just their schooling.

  1. Physical fitness: Umpiring requires agility and endurance. Umpires must be able to crouch quickly, move swiftly, and remain on their feet for long periods of time during games. It is essential that umpires maintain good physical conditioning to meet these demands.

  2. Game knowledge: A thorough understanding of the rules of baseball is crucial for an umpire. Knowing how to interpret and apply the rules in various game situations is an essential component of the job.

  3. Communication skills: Umpires must be able to effectively communicate with players, coaches, and other officials. Strong listening and speaking skills, combined with a clear voice and the ability to remain calm in high-pressure situations, are important for success.

  4. Professionalism: The role of an umpire requires them to display professionalism at all times. This includes maintaining an appropriate appearance, making impartial judgments, and demonstrating respect for the integrity of the game and its participants.

Evaluation and Performance Assessments

Minor league umpires are subject to regular evaluation and performance assessments throughout the baseball season. These assessments are conducted by the Professional Baseball Umpire Corp (PBUC) staff, who attend games and monitor umpire performance.

Evaluations focus on several areas, including on-field mechanics, rule interpretations, game management, and overall conduct. Umpires receive written feedback regarding their performance, as well as verbal guidance during in-person meetings with evaluators. These assessments play an essential role in an umpire’s development, providing them with valuable insight and identifying areas for improvement.

Mentorship and Continued Education

As minor league umpires advance through the various levels of professional baseball, the opportunity to learn from experienced colleagues and mentors becomes increasingly important. Veteran umpires often provide guidance and support to their less-experienced counterparts, helping them to develop both their skills and their confidence.

In addition to mentorship, minor league umpires participate in mandatory continuing education programs throughout their careers. These programs include refresher courses on rules and mechanics, as well as seminars on topics such as sports psychology, nutrition, and injury prevention.

It is through this ongoing education, combined with hands-on experience and the guidance of mentors, that minor league umpires continue to hone their skills and work towards the ultimate goal of reaching the Major League level. Overall, the training and development process for minor league umpires is rigorous yet essential in ensuring professional growth and success in the demanding world of professional baseball officiating.

Minor League Baseball Umpire Officiating Levels

Minor league baseball umpires, as well as players, have to work their way up through the ranks to make it to the major leagues. They begin their careers in the lowest levels of professional baseball and ascend through the classification system based on their skill, experience, and success. There are four main levels of minor league baseball umpiring: Rookie League and Short-Season, Class A, Double-A, and Triple-A.

Rookie League and Short-Season

The Rookie League and Short-Season leagues represent the entry point for aspiring minor league baseball umpires. These leagues are the first taste of professional baseball for both players and umpires. The games and league play in these levels are typically shorter than at the higher tiers, allowing umpires to gain experience and develop their skills in a shortened time frame.

Rookie League and Short-Season baseball are designed to be developmental leagues, so the focus is on learning and improving as opposed to competition. Teams in these leagues usually consist of recently signed or drafted players, many of whom are just beginning their professional careers. Officiating games in this tier can provide umpires with valuable experience in dealing with players that come from various backgrounds and skill sets.

Umpires in the Rookie League and Short-Season leagues are typically recent graduates of professional umpiring academies. They are evaluated on their performance, and the most promising umpires are promoted to higher levels of the minor leagues.

Class A

Class A baseball is the next step up in the minor league system, and it’s split into two different levels – Class A and Class A-Advanced. Class A is still considered a developmental league, but the competition is more intense than in the Rookie League or Short-Season leagues.

Umpiring in Class A involves working games involving more experienced players, who often have a better understanding of the rules and strategies involved in professional baseball. As a result, an umpire’s ability to manage the game, make accurate calls, and demonstrate a thorough understanding of the rules is crucial at this level.

Umpires in Class A leagues are typically those who have shown promise and success at the lower levels of the minor leagues. They are expected to continue refining their skills and learning how to deal with the increased demands of higher-level baseball, which often includes larger crowds, more media attention, and a higher level of competition.


Double-A baseball represents the middle tier of the minor league system, and it’s often considered the most significant jump in terms of competition and skill level for both players and umpires. Many major league organizations use their Double-A affiliates to develop their most promising prospects, and the level of play is significantly higher than in Class A.

As a result, umpires working in Double-A baseball must be prepared to handle more challenging game situations, deal with highly skilled players and more experienced coaches, and make split-second decisions that will have a significant impact on the outcome of games.

A promotion to Double-A is a significant milestone in an umpire’s career, as most major league umpires have experience at this level before making the jump to Triple-A or the major leagues. Umpires in Double-A are typically highly regarded and have demonstrated a high level of competency throughout their minor league careers.


Triple-A baseball is the highest level of minor league baseball, and it’s just one step away from the major leagues. Triple-A umpires will regularly handle games featuring some of the best prospects in baseball, as well as players on major league rehabilitation assignments or veterans looking to work their way back to the big leagues.

At this level, umpires must display an expert knowledge of the rules, highly developed game management skills, and the ability to handle high-pressure situations. Performance in Triple-A will often determine whether an umpire will be considered for a promotion to the major league level.

Umpiring in Triple-A baseball requires a high level of skill, dedication, and perseverance, as opportunities for advancement to the major leagues can be extremely limited. However, Triple-A umpires are considered the best in the minor leagues, and their work in these games often serves as their final audition before reaching the pinnacle of professional baseball officiating – the major leagues.

Career Progression and Promotion to Major League Baseball

As a baseball umpire, reaching the major leagues is the pinnacle of one’s career. However, getting there requires perseverance, dedication, and hard work. In this section, we will explore the career progression and promotion process for aspiring Major League Baseball umpires. We will discuss how to reach the MLB umpire pool, assessments and selection processes, filling vacancies in the Major League, and the transition period for new MLB umpires.

Reaching the MLB Umpire Pool

To reach the MLB umpire pool, one must first start at the minor league level. Candidates generally begin their careers as amateur umpires officiating Little League, high school, and college games. To progress to professional baseball, umpires must attend one of the two accredited umpire schools. These schools usually consist of month-long intensive training programs that provide one aspiring umpires with the necessary skills and knowledge for officiating professional games.

Upon graduating from umpire school, successful candidates will then attend an evaluation course, also known as the umpire camp, where they’ll be assessed based on their performance. A select few will be hired to work as minor league umpires. The minor leagues are divided into several levels (Rookie, Class A, Class AA, Class AAA), and the umpires will begin at the lower ranks, working their way up through the different levels as they gain experience and develop their skills.

It’s essential for an umpire to consistently demonstrate good judgment, excellent communication, and strong on-field management skills to progress further in their career. They must also meet stringent physical fitness standards and maintain an excellent rule knowledge. Progression through the minor leagues can take several years, and at each level, only the top-performing candidates will be considered for a promotion.

Assessments and Selection Process

Throughout their careers, minor league umpires are monitored and evaluated by supervisors and experienced umpires who act as mentors. Regular assessments occur based on on-field performance, knowledge of the rules, physical fitness, and overall professionalism.

When vacancies occur in the Major League umpire pool, the selection process begins at the Class AAA level. The General Managers of each MLB team, in consultation with the MLB Umpire Department, evaluate the potential candidates. Factors taken into consideration for promotion include previous evaluations, recommendations from supervisors, and experience in different levels of the minor leagues. In addition to their performance, the MLB looks for a strong work ethic, teamwork, and the ability to handle high-pressure situations in potential umpires.

Filling Vacancies in the Major League

There are 76 full-time umpire positions in the Major League Baseball, and vacancies can arise due to retirements, injuries, or terminations. When a vacancy occurs, a suitable replacement is chosen from the MLB umpire pool. Initially, the chosen umpire may be appointed as a temporary or part-time employee, with the possibility of being promoted to a full-time position based on their performance and the league’s needs.

Promotions to the MLB are scarce, and aspiring umpires face high levels of competition for these opportunities. Many umpires in the minor leagues may never reach the major leagues, despite years of dedication and hard work.

Transition Period for New MLB Umpires

Once an umpire has been promoted to the Major League level, they will undergo a transition period to acclimate to the increased demands and expectations associated with MLB games. This initial period may include working as a part-time or fill-in umpire, partnering with more experienced umpires, attending league meetings, and receiving additional guidance and support from MLB staff and supervisors.

As a new MLB umpire, they will be expected to continue honing their skills, rule knowledge, and professionalism. Additionally, they may also be asked to participate in public appearances, media interviews, and community events – all of which contribute to their overall reputation and qualifications as an MLB umpire.

In summary, the journey to becoming a Major League Baseball umpire is a challenging and competitive one. Candidates must remain dedicated and committed to their craft and constantly work on improving their skills while progressing through the ranks. Only the best of the best will ultimately receive the prestigious honor of officiating in the MLB.

Challenges Faced by Minor League Baseball Umpires

Minor League Baseball (MiLB) umpires face an array of challenges in their journey to establish themselves in the world of professional baseball. Many are unaware of the difficulties these dedicated individuals face, and this article aims to highlight some of these struggles. The challenges discussed include travel and lifestyle adjustments, lower pay compared to Major League umpires, handling pressure and criticism, and dealing with injuries and health issues.

Travel and Lifestyle Adjustments

One significant challenge faced by MiLB umpires is the constant travel that comes with their profession. They frequently find themselves on the road, driving long distances to reach the next game. This hectic schedule can take a toll on their personal lives, resulting in missed family events, birthdays, and other milestones. Additionally, the constant relocation can cause feelings of isolation and loneliness, which can negatively impact their mental health.

MiLB umpires often live in less-than-ideal accommodations, as they are typically provided with a housing stipend that doesn’t quite cover their expenses. As a result, they frequently bunk with their fellow umpires in cramped apartments or hotel rooms. Furthermore, their schedule offers little time for rest and leisure, as they often work late nights and have to be prepared to leave for their next destination the following morning. Unfortunately, these difficult lifestyle adjustments can put added strain on relationships, making it harder to maintain a stable personal life and create emotional connections.

Lower Pay Compared to Major League Umpires

Perhaps the most glaring challenge faced by MiLB umpires is their drastically lower pay in comparison to their Major League counterparts. While Major League umpires can earn a steady income ranging from $100,000 to $300,000 per year, MiLB umpires earn significantly less. In fact, most minor league umpires only make around $20,000 a year. This pay gap persists even as the umpires climb the ranks, making it harder to break into the Major League for higher pay.

The disparity in pay is not reflective of the quality of work, as MiLB umpires maintain the same professionalism and dedication as those in the Major League. However, this difficult financial situation forces many minor league umpires to take on additional jobs in the offseason to make ends meet. It is also worth mentioning that minor league umpires lack financial security, as their job security is not guaranteed, and they can be released at any time.

Handling Pressure and Criticism

MiLB umpires must cope with immense pressure in their roles as they strive to maintain the integrity of the game. Since their performance is critical to the outcome of each game, they must remain sharp and focused over an entire season, which spans from April to September.

Additionally, minor league umpires often deal with criticism and backlash from players, coaches, and fans, who tend to be more vocal in their displeasure at perceived bad calls. Learning to handle this criticism, especially when it borders on having a hostile working environment, is an essential skill for minor league umpires to develop. These experiences can serve as a valuable learning opportunity and prepare them for the even more intense environment of Major League Baseball.

Dealing with Injuries and Health Issues

The physical demands of being an MiLB umpire can lead to various injuries and health issues over time. These may include strains or bruises from being hit by balls and collisions with players, or simply the toll of constant wear and tear on their bodies from constant standing, squatting, and moving.

Moreover, the lifestyle of a minor league umpire is not always conducive to optimal health. The long hours spent in the car driving to games, combined with limited time for sleep and exercise, can negatively impact their overall well-being. The requirement to perform at their best, despite these challenges, is yet another hurdle that MiLB umpires must overcome in their quest to one day join the ranks of their Major League counterparts.

Major League Baseball Umpires

Jerry Meals

Jerry Meals is widely regarded as one of the premier umpires in Major League Baseball (MLB) today. His journey from a minor league umpire to an MLB umpire is one of hard work, dedication, and perseverance. Born in October, 1961, in Pennsylvania, Meals began his professional umpiring career in 1983 after attending the Harry Wendelstedt Umpire School. Throughout the 1980s and early 1990s, Meals worked his way up the ranks in the minor leagues, earning a reputation for his strong attention to detail and keen eye for the rulebook. He would spend around 14 years in the minor league before first joining the MLB umpire staff in 1992. He became a full-time MLB umpire in 1997 and has since officiated some of the most crucial moments in baseball, including the 2008 and 2014 World Series, the 2002 and 2015 All-Star Games, and numerous playoff games.

Joe West

Joe West, affectionately known as “Cowboy Joe,” is another notable minor league umpire turned MLB umpire. West was born in October, 1952, in North Carolina, and he began his professional career by attending the Bill Kinnamon Umpire School in 1974. He quickly caught the attention of MLB talent scouts and was promoted through the minor leagues at a rapid pace. By 1976, West was already working as a MLB umpire, and he has since amassed a resume that includes over 5,300 games, making him the longest tenured umpire in the history of the league.

Throughout his successful career, West has officiated six World Series, nine League Championship Series, and three All-Star games. He has been a polarizing figure in the world of baseball, known for his flamboyant style and strong personality. Despite this, West has thrived in a challenging profession and has earned recognition as one of the most recognizable umpires in the sport.

Angel Hernandez

Angel Hernandez, born in 1961 in Havana, Cuba, began his umpiring career attending the Joe Brinkman Umpire School in 1984. He worked his way up the minor league system, earning a reputation for his hard work and diligence both on and off the field. After a few years of officiating, Hernandez was promoted to Triple-A, the highest level of minor league baseball. He would then become a regular MLB umpire in 1993.

Throughout his 28-year MLB career, Hernandez has been chosen to officiate four Division Series, seven Championship Series, two All-Star Games, and the 2005 World Series. His determination, perseverance, and commitment to the job have made him a notable MLB umpire.

Fieldin Culbreth

Fieldin Culbreth, born in 1963 in South Carolina, is another prominent minor league umpire who turned into an MLB umpire. After attending the Bill Kinnamon Umpire School in 1987, Culbreth worked his way through the minor league ranks and became a part of the MLB umpire staff in 1993. In his illustrious career, Culbreth has officiated four Division Series, seven League Championship Series, the 2008 and 2012 World Series, and the 2006 and 2014 MLB All-Star Games.

These umpires have shown tremendous dedication, determination, and hard work in their journey from minor league to MLB officiating. Their commitment to excellence and love for the game have earned them the respect and admiration of players, coaches, and fans alike.

Minor League Baseball Umpires-FAQs

1. What is the role of a Minor League Baseball umpire?

A Minor League Baseball umpire is responsible for enforcing the rules and maintaining order during a baseball game. Key duties include making calls on plays, ensuring proper game flow, and arbitrating disputes between players and coaches.

2. What training do Minor League Baseball umpires undergo?

Minor League Baseball umpires attend professional umpire school to learn the rules, mechanics, and on-field communication expected at the professional level. After completing the school, umpires advance through Minor League Baseball’s development and evaluation process before being considered for promotion.

3. What can players expect in terms of professionalism from a Minor League Baseball umpire?

Players can expect Minor League Baseball umpires to be highly skilled, knowledgeable about the rules, and fair in their decision-making. Umpires must demonstrate consistent judgment, maintain a professional demeanor, and exhibit effective communication skills.

4. How are Minor League Baseball umpires evaluated and promoted?

Minor League Baseball umpires receive regular evaluations by supervisors who observe their work, provide feedback, and document performance. Umpires also undergo performance evaluations, which assess factors such as rules knowledge, mechanics, and appearance. Based on these assessments, umpires may be promoted to higher-level leagues or selected for MLB opportunities.

5. What is the salary range for a Minor League Baseball umpire?

The salary range for a Minor League Baseball umpire varies depending on experience and the level of competition. Entry-level umpires typically earn around $2,000 per month, while umpires working in Triple-A can make upwards of $4,000 per month during the season.

6. How do Minor League Baseball umpires transition to the Major League Baseball level?

Minor League Baseball umpires who demonstrate exceptional performance and meet evaluation criteria may be called up to work Major League Baseball games on a fill-in basis. Umpires with consistently strong evaluations and experience working at the highest minor league levels have the best chance of being hired as full-time MLB umpires.

More Posts

When Did CT Legalize Gambling?

Connecticut has a rich history of gambling, with a diverse range of options available to residents. From casinos and horse racing tracks to the ever-popular

What Is The Best Sportsbook App In CT?

Imagine this: you’re a sports enthusiast in Connecticut, eagerly looking for the best sportsbook app to elevate your betting experience. Get ready to discover the

Does CT Tax Gambling Winnings?

Did you know that Connecticut imposes income tax on gambling winnings? That’s right, if you’ve hit the jackpot or had a lucky streak at the

Table of Contents


Send Us A Message